North Devon World Surfing Reserve

North devon is now a world surfing reserve

North Devon is now a world surfing reserve, marking a significant milestone for the region’s surfing community and beyond. This designation promises exciting changes, from boosting tourism to shaping sustainable surfing practices. We’ll delve into the historical context of surfing in North Devon, examine the impacts of this new status, and explore the global significance of this initiative.

The designation considers factors like the existing surfing infrastructure, potential economic benefits, environmental effects, and community perspectives. It also analyzes how the reserve will address access for all, manage crowds, and prioritize sustainability. This is a comprehensive look at the future of surfing in North Devon, including a detailed vision for the reserve’s ongoing development and management.

Table of Contents

Historical Context of Surfing in North Devon

North Devon, a region famed for its dramatic coastline and powerful waves, has a rich and evolving history with surfing. From humble beginnings to a globally recognized surfing destination, the region’s surf culture has witnessed significant transformations. This exploration delves into the historical evolution of surfing in North Devon, highlighting key events, influential figures, and the unique characteristics of its surfing culture.

We will also compare and contrast its development with other surfing hubs and assess the current infrastructure supporting the surfing community.The region’s distinctive geological formations and consistent swells have always attracted adventurous spirits seeking the thrill of riding the waves. The early days of surfing in North Devon were marked by a sense of exploration and discovery, with surfers gradually developing their techniques and understanding of the local conditions.

Over time, this evolved into a more structured and organized community, contributing to the vibrant surfing culture we see today.

Early Days and Shaping Influences

Surfing in North Devon, like elsewhere, began with individuals drawn to the ocean’s power. Early accounts suggest that surfers were inspired by indigenous practices and gradually developed their own unique style, influenced by the specific wave patterns and coastal conditions. The region’s isolated nature contributed to a distinct local identity, setting it apart from other surfing areas. The development of surfing in North Devon was influenced by both the local environment and broader global trends in surfing.

North Devon’s just been named a world surfing reserve, which is awesome! Packing for all those future epic waves? You might want to check out the Walmart Gonex travel duffel bag sale – perfect for hauling your board and gear. Walmart Gonex travel duffel bag sale This means even more incredible surfing opportunities for the region, which is fantastic news for all the passionate surfers out there.

Key Events and Figures in North Devon’s Surfing History

North Devon’s surfing history has been shaped by various significant events and individuals. The emergence of dedicated surf breaks, such as Croyde Bay and Woolacombe Beach, played a crucial role in attracting surfers and fostering the growth of the local community. Key figures, whether locals or visitors, who championed the sport and contributed to its development, helped to build the foundation of the local surfing culture.

Evolution of Surfing Culture in North Devon

The evolution of surfing culture in North Devon is characterized by a blend of local traditions and global influences. Early surfers developed techniques and strategies based on the unique conditions of the waves and coast. As the sport grew in popularity, North Devon’s surfing culture began to incorporate international trends and styles, but always maintaining a distinct local character.

The local community’s emphasis on environmental stewardship and respecting the natural beauty of the coast became integral to the culture.

Infrastructure and Support Systems

The existing infrastructure and support systems for surfers in North Devon are crucial for the continued growth and success of the surfing community. Dedicated surf schools, surf shops, and accommodation options cater to the needs of surfers, offering a range of services and resources. Local surf clubs and organizations provide platforms for networking and community building, promoting a strong sense of camaraderie among surfers.

This infrastructure facilitates the enjoyment and progression of surfing within the region.

Comparison with Other Surfing Locations Globally

Comparing North Devon’s surfing development with other global locations reveals unique aspects of its evolution. While other regions may have established earlier surf traditions or stronger international competitions, North Devon’s surfing culture evolved organically, deeply rooted in the local environment and community. The emphasis on sustainability and respect for the natural environment, evident in North Devon’s surfing culture, differentiates it from some other surfing locations globally.

Impacts of the Designation as a World Surfing Reserve

North Devon’s recent designation as a World Surfing Reserve marks a significant turning point for the region. This prestigious recognition promises a wealth of opportunities, but also presents challenges that need careful consideration. The impact extends beyond the surfing community, affecting tourism, the environment, and local residents. The benefits and drawbacks will be felt throughout the area, from the bustling beaches to the quiet coastal villages.

Economic Benefits for Tourism and Local Businesses

The designation as a World Surfing Reserve is expected to attract a substantial influx of tourists, both domestic and international. This increased visitor traffic will directly benefit North Devon’s tourism sector, boosting local businesses like hotels, restaurants, and surf shops. The surge in demand could lead to job creation and improved livelihoods for local people. For example, similar designations in other coastal areas have seen a notable rise in visitor numbers and corresponding economic activity.

See also  Best Places to See Berlin Street Art

This increased tourism will also stimulate related businesses like surf-related equipment rentals, accommodation providers, and surf lesson providers.

Environmental Effects and Conservation Efforts

The designation will likely lead to enhanced conservation efforts for the region’s unique coastal environment. This includes improved protection of crucial habitats, such as nesting sites for seabirds and marine life. Dedicated management plans will be crucial in maintaining the delicate balance of the ecosystem. However, increased visitor numbers could also pose challenges. Managing visitor access and minimizing the environmental footprint of tourists will be paramount.

North Devon’s just been named a world surfing reserve, which is awesome! While I’m stoked about the waves, I’ve been researching the best national parks in Sri Lanka lately. Exploring those lush landscapes and incredible biodiversity could be a great alternative if you’re looking for a different kind of adventure from the world-class surfing in North Devon. Best national parks Sri Lanka offer a totally different experience, but North Devon’s surfing scene is still top-notch, regardless.

Careful planning and infrastructure development, including designated parking areas and waste management systems, are vital to mitigate potential negative impacts. Examples of similar designations globally show that sustainable tourism practices are key to preserving the natural beauty of the area while ensuring its accessibility to visitors.

Social Implications for the Surfing Community and Local Residents

The designation will likely have significant social implications for both the surfing community and local residents. The increased popularity of surfing could potentially lead to overcrowding at popular surf spots, requiring the implementation of management strategies to ensure equitable access for all surfers. There may also be concerns about the impact on local communities, potentially involving traffic congestion and strain on local infrastructure.

Careful planning and communication with local residents are crucial to ensure a positive experience for everyone. Consideration of the existing infrastructure, traffic patterns, and community needs will help navigate these potential social impacts.

Changes in Regulations and Management of Surfing in the Region

The designation will necessitate changes in the regulations and management of surfing in North Devon. These changes could involve establishing surf zones, limiting access during peak periods, or implementing guidelines for responsible surfing behavior. New signage, communication channels, and patrols might be necessary to ensure safety and compliance. The goal will be to balance the need to protect the environment with the desire to maintain a vibrant and welcoming surfing culture.

The management approach should be transparent, incorporating feedback from surfers, local residents, and environmental experts.

Comparison of Pre- and Post-Designation Impacts

Aspect Pre-Designation Post-Designation
Surfing Culture Relatively local, with a focus on community and camaraderie. Limited access for tourists. More diverse and globalized, with increased tourist participation. Potential for a wider range of surfers to enjoy the region.
Infrastructure Limited facilities for tourists, such as parking and changing rooms. Basic support for local surf businesses. Improved infrastructure for tourists, including parking areas, public facilities, and better support for surf-related businesses. Increased investment in infrastructure and facilities.
Environmental Impact Limited environmental impact management. Potentially some localized pollution or unsustainable practices. Stronger environmental conservation efforts, including protected zones and waste management systems. Potential for a decrease in environmental damage.
Economic Impact Limited tourist revenue. Local businesses rely on local clientele. Increased tourist revenue. Potential for economic growth and job creation in the tourism sector.

Global Significance of North Devon’s World Surfing Reserve Status

North Devon’s designation as a World Surfing Reserve marks a significant step towards recognizing the global importance of this coastal region. It transcends a simple geographical label, highlighting the interconnectedness of surfing, environment, and tourism. This designation carries the potential to serve as a model for other locations, promoting sustainable practices and inspiring global conversations about conservation and responsible recreation.This new status opens a pathway for North Devon to not only showcase its exceptional surf breaks but also to act as a beacon of sustainable tourism.

It can inspire similar initiatives globally, pushing for a balance between economic development and environmental preservation. The ripple effects of this designation extend far beyond the North Devon coast, influencing practices and policies worldwide.

Global Impact on Surfing Practices

North Devon’s recognition as a World Surfing Reserve will undoubtedly inspire responsible surfing practices on a global scale. By establishing stringent guidelines and promoting education, North Devon sets a precedent for other surfing destinations. This commitment to conservation and environmental stewardship fosters a shift in mindset among surfers, encouraging them to adopt sustainable behaviors. These include minimizing environmental impact, respecting marine life, and upholding responsible waste management.

North Devon’s just become a world surfing reserve – awesome news for wave riders! But while you’re dreaming of catching the perfect North Devon wave, you might also be picturing a different kind of adventure, like planning your dream Himalayan trip. Thinking about trekking through the mountains and exploring ancient monasteries? Then check out this guide to planning your dream Himalayan trip – it’s packed with tips and resources to help you plan your epic expedition.

No matter which adventure you choose, North Devon’s new status as a surfing reserve is definitely a destination to consider!

This proactive approach will likely encourage similar initiatives in other surfing hot spots worldwide, promoting a collective consciousness about the importance of responsible environmental practices within the surfing community.

Potential for Sustainable Surfing Tourism

The reserve’s establishment presents an opportunity for North Devon to become a model for sustainable surfing tourism. This approach prioritizes minimizing environmental impact while maximizing economic benefits for the local community. Implementing sustainable practices like eco-friendly accommodation, waste reduction initiatives, and promoting public transport can set a standard for responsible tourism. This model can then be replicated in other surfing destinations, demonstrating that economic growth and environmental preservation are not mutually exclusive.

For example, the success of sustainable tourism initiatives in Costa Rica, focusing on ecotourism, can serve as a model for North Devon’s approach to environmentally conscious tourism.

Research and Development Opportunities

North Devon’s unique wave patterns and diverse marine ecosystem provide an unparalleled opportunity for research and development in surfing, wave science, and conservation. Researchers can study wave dynamics, coastal erosion, and the impact of human activity on marine environments. This knowledge can be instrumental in developing innovative solutions for coastal management and conservation. Furthermore, this focus on research can contribute to a deeper understanding of the relationship between human activity and the natural environment.

Promoting Responsible and Sustainable Surfing Practices

North Devon’s role in promoting responsible and sustainable surfing practices is crucial. By implementing educational programs and awareness campaigns, the reserve can foster a culture of environmental stewardship within the surfing community. These programs will inform surfers about the importance of responsible waste management, minimizing their impact on marine life, and respecting the delicate balance of the coastal ecosystem.

This commitment to sustainability can inspire other surfing communities to adopt similar initiatives.

See also  Best Surfing in Indonesia A Surfers Paradise

Global Impact on Surfing and Tourism (Table)

Aspect Global Impact
Surfing Practices Increased awareness and adoption of responsible surfing practices globally, inspiring similar initiatives in other locations.
Sustainable Tourism Model for sustainable tourism in surfing destinations worldwide, promoting a balance between economic benefits and environmental protection.
Research and Development Enhanced understanding of wave science, coastal ecosystems, and the impact of human activity, leading to the development of innovative solutions for conservation and management.
Conservation Promoting responsible resource management and environmental protection, potentially inspiring similar efforts in other coastal areas.
Education and Awareness Increased awareness and understanding of the importance of sustainable practices within the surfing community, fostering a culture of environmental stewardship.

Community and Stakeholder Perspectives: North Devon Is Now A World Surfing Reserve

North devon is now a world surfing reserve

The designation of North Devon as a World Surfing Reserve brings a complex interplay of hopes and concerns. Local communities, surfers, businesses, and environmental groups hold diverse perspectives on the potential impacts, both positive and negative, of this significant step. Understanding these varied viewpoints is crucial for crafting a successful and sustainable future for surfing in the region. Successful implementation requires a collaborative approach that values the input of all stakeholders.

Stakeholder Views and Concerns

Various stakeholders in North Devon hold diverse perspectives regarding the World Surfing Reserve. Their concerns and hopes are multifaceted, ranging from economic opportunities to environmental protection.

Stakeholder Group Potential Views and Concerns
Local Communities Potential for increased tourism and economic benefits, but also concerns about potential disruption to their way of life, increased traffic, and pressure on local resources. Concerns over increased housing demand and potential for gentrification are also relevant.
Surfers Desire for preservation of waves and surfing culture, but also concern over potential restrictions on access and competition from increased tourism. Concerns regarding maintaining the authenticity of the surfing experience are paramount.
Businesses (e.g., surf shops, accommodation providers) Potential for significant economic growth, but also concern over potential regulations impacting their operations. Uncertainty about attracting the right type of tourism and managing the influx of visitors is a common concern.
Environmental Groups Support for the reserve’s environmental protection goals, but also concern over potential negative impacts on marine ecosystems and coastal habitats. Concerns regarding sustainable tourism practices and the management of waste are important considerations.

Role of Local Stakeholders in Shaping the Future

Local stakeholders play a vital role in shaping the future of surfing in North Devon. Their active participation in the planning, implementation, and ongoing management of the reserve is essential. By actively engaging with communities, surfers, businesses, and environmental groups, a more comprehensive and successful approach to managing the reserve can be achieved. This collaborative approach will lead to a more balanced and sustainable future for the region.

Potential Conflicts and Challenges

Implementing the reserve’s goals may face various conflicts and challenges. Balancing the needs of conservation with the economic opportunities presented by increased tourism is a key challenge. Potential conflicts could arise between different stakeholder groups. For example, surfers may feel their access to waves is limited by conservation efforts, while businesses may feel that regulations impede their growth.

Furthermore, disagreements about the extent of development permitted in the region and how to manage increased traffic are significant challenges.

Community Engagement for Reserve Management

Community engagement is critical for the effective management of the World Surfing Reserve. A structured process for gathering feedback from diverse stakeholders is necessary. Such a process should include regular meetings, online forums, and dedicated feedback channels to facilitate open dialogue and ensure that the needs of all parties are considered.

Structured Format for Community Feedback

A structured format for community feedback regarding the reserve’s designation is crucial. This should include online surveys, feedback forms, and dedicated email addresses. Furthermore, public meetings and town hall discussions should be facilitated to allow for direct interaction between stakeholders and decision-makers. These mechanisms should promote transparency and ensure that all perspectives are heard.

Infrastructure and Access

North devon is now a world surfing reserve

North Devon’s designation as a world surfing reserve presents a fantastic opportunity for enhanced visitor experience and sustainable tourism. Crucially, this requires thoughtful planning and investment in infrastructure to support the influx of surfers and visitors while preserving the natural beauty of the region. The improvements detailed below aim to facilitate access, manage crowds effectively, and ensure the long-term health of the surfing locations.Investing in the necessary infrastructure is paramount to supporting the growing popularity of North Devon as a surfing destination.

This will ensure that the region can effectively manage the influx of visitors while preserving the environment and the unique character of the surfing experience.

Potential Improvements to Surfing Infrastructure

Providing improved facilities like car parks, changing rooms, and information centers is essential to enhance the visitor experience. These facilities will contribute to a more organized and enjoyable experience for all users, from seasoned surfers to casual visitors. Adequate parking will mitigate traffic congestion and ease access, while well-maintained changing rooms will enhance hygiene and comfort. A dedicated information center will provide crucial information on local surfing conditions, safety guidelines, and the rich history of the region.

Accessibility for People with Disabilities

Ensuring full accessibility for people with disabilities is a critical aspect of fostering inclusivity. This involves the design of facilities and access routes that are compliant with accessibility standards, providing ramps, accessible changing rooms, and well-marked pathways. This proactive approach will encourage participation from a wider range of people and demonstrate the region’s commitment to inclusivity. For example, the design of new car parks should consider accessible parking spaces, and changing rooms should be designed with accessible facilities.

Managing Crowds and Ensuring Sustainable Use

Managing crowds is vital to maintaining the quality of the surfing experience and protecting the environment. Strategies to manage crowds include implementing timed entry systems, designated parking zones, and clear signage to direct visitors. This will minimize congestion and disruption at peak times. Implementing a system of designated surfing areas based on skill level could also help to manage crowd density in high-traffic zones.

By employing these strategies, we can ensure the sustainable use of the surfing locations and maintain their appeal for future generations.

Improving Public Transport Access

Improving public transport access will reduce reliance on private vehicles, minimizing environmental impact and promoting a more sustainable tourism model. This could involve increasing the frequency of bus services to key surfing locations, establishing dedicated surf shuttles, or exploring the feasibility of cycle paths that connect surfing spots. These initiatives will make surfing more accessible to a wider range of visitors, especially those who prefer eco-friendly travel options.

For example, a dedicated shuttle service connecting major towns and surfing spots could be implemented, complementing existing bus routes.

Potential Infrastructure Improvements and Estimated Costs

Infrastructure Improvement Estimated Cost (GBP)
New Car Park (with accessible spaces) £500,000 – £1,000,000
Improved Changing Rooms (accessible) £200,000 – £500,000
Information Centre £150,000 – £300,000
Dedicated Surf Shuttle Service £100,000 – £250,000 (annual running cost)
Signage and Wayfinding Improvements £20,000 – £50,000
See also  Trip Ideas Frevo, Art, Greenwich Village

Note: These are estimated costs and may vary based on specific project requirements and local factors.

Environmental Considerations and Sustainability

North Devon’s designation as a World Surfing Reserve presents a unique opportunity to integrate environmental protection with the vibrant surfing culture. This designation, beyond promoting surfing tourism, necessitates a proactive approach to safeguarding the delicate coastal ecosystems and ensuring long-term sustainability. The reserve’s success hinges on understanding and addressing the environmental impacts of surfing, while leveraging the opportunity to foster environmental stewardship.This dedicated approach to environmental responsibility extends beyond just the immediate surfing environment.

It encompasses the entire coastal region, recognising the interconnectedness of the marine and terrestrial ecosystems. This holistic view allows for the protection of a wider range of biodiversity and the preservation of unique coastal habitats.

Environmental Benefits of the Designation

The World Surfing Reserve designation acts as a catalyst for positive environmental change. It provides a framework for implementing sustainable practices, encouraging a shift towards responsible tourism and reducing the negative impacts of human activity on the region’s delicate ecosystems. The designation fosters a greater appreciation for the environmental importance of the area, driving both local and global conservation efforts.

Biodiversity Conservation and Coastal Habitat Protection

The diverse coastal habitats of North Devon, from sandy beaches to rocky reefs, support a rich array of marine life. The reserve designation can lead to specific conservation plans tailored to protect endangered species and sensitive habitats. This includes the implementation of marine protected areas, enhancing habitat restoration projects, and reducing pollution levels. Protecting coastal habitats is vital to safeguarding the region’s ecological balance and ensuring the long-term viability of surfing and related activities.

Education and Awareness Campaigns

Education plays a critical role in promoting environmental responsibility. Dedicated awareness campaigns can educate the public about the importance of sustainable practices in the surfing community and the wider coastal area. These campaigns can include workshops, educational materials, and partnerships with local schools and organizations. This fosters a sense of shared responsibility for protecting the environment, ensuring that environmental awareness permeates all aspects of the region’s activities.

Mitigating Negative Environmental Impacts of Surfing

Surfing, while a popular and environmentally-friendly activity, can have some negative impacts if not managed responsibly. For instance, improper waste disposal, improper use of equipment, and excessive noise levels during competitions can negatively affect the surrounding environment. Effective management strategies are needed to mitigate these impacts, such as promoting responsible waste management, encouraging eco-friendly equipment choices, and establishing noise restrictions.

Suggested Actions for Sustainable Surfing Practices

  • Waste Management: Implementation of comprehensive waste management systems, including recycling programs and designated waste disposal points, will help minimize the impact of litter on coastal areas. Examples of such programs are already in place at many surfing locations internationally.
  • Eco-friendly Equipment: Promoting the use of eco-friendly surfing equipment, such as biodegradable or recycled materials, will reduce the environmental footprint of the sport. Companies producing surfboards and other equipment could be encouraged to adopt sustainable practices.
  • Sustainable Transportation: Encouraging public transportation, cycling, and walking for travel to surfing locations, and providing designated parking areas can minimize the environmental impact of commuting. This approach promotes a reduction in carbon emissions.
  • Noise Management: Implementing noise restrictions during competitions or events will minimize disturbance to wildlife and reduce the impact of loud music or amplified sounds.
  • Responsible Water Usage: Implementing water-saving measures, like reducing water consumption in surf-related facilities and promoting responsible water use in everyday activities, will ensure the sustainable use of water resources. This also applies to the maintenance of the equipment used for surfing.

Future of Surfing in North Devon

North Devon’s designation as a World Surfing Reserve presents a unique opportunity to shape the future of surfing in the region. This isn’t just about preserving waves; it’s about fostering a sustainable and thriving surfing community for generations to come, while balancing the needs of the environment and local economy. The vision for the future must consider the reserve’s global impact, local engagement, and long-term ecological sustainability.The future hinges on a proactive approach, embracing innovation, and integrating sustainable practices into all aspects of the surfing industry.

This will ensure North Devon’s position as a leading surfing destination, attracting both local and international surfers while safeguarding the environment for future generations.

A Vision for Sustainable Growth

North Devon’s future as a World Surfing Reserve demands a holistic approach that considers the interconnectedness of environmental stewardship, community engagement, and economic prosperity. The reserve must be more than just a collection of surf breaks; it needs to be a vibrant ecosystem that supports the well-being of all stakeholders.

Potential Opportunities for Growth and Development, North devon is now a world surfing reserve

A crucial aspect of the reserve’s future is the identification and development of opportunities that enhance the region’s surfing appeal. These can range from innovative tourism packages to advanced educational initiatives. Such ventures should be sustainable, ensuring that economic growth does not compromise the environment.

  • Enhanced Infrastructure: Investment in accessible and sustainable infrastructure, such as improved car parks, public transport links, and eco-friendly accommodation options, can significantly improve the visitor experience and minimize environmental impact. For instance, the development of electric vehicle charging stations in key locations can align with the region’s environmental goals.
  • Community Engagement: Active involvement of local communities is essential. This can include community workshops, surf camps for young people, and initiatives that promote the local economy and culture, showcasing the unique charm of the region.
  • Educational Initiatives: Establishing surf schools, courses, and workshops that combine surfing instruction with environmental education can help visitors understand the delicate balance of the region’s marine ecosystem and contribute to a more responsible surfing community.

Importance of Ongoing Monitoring and Evaluation

Regular monitoring and evaluation of the reserve’s impact are crucial for its long-term success. Data collection on wave conditions, environmental factors, and visitor numbers is essential to understand the effects of the designation. This allows for proactive adjustments and refinements in management strategies, ensuring that the reserve remains a valuable asset for future generations.

  • Baseline Data: Establishing baseline data on key environmental indicators like water quality, wildlife populations, and coastal erosion patterns is paramount. This provides a benchmark against which future changes can be measured.
  • Regular Assessments: Regular assessments of the reserve’s impact on various aspects, from tourism numbers to the well-being of local communities, will ensure that the reserve continues to meet its goals and addresses any unforeseen challenges.
  • Adaptive Management: Using the collected data to adapt management strategies as needed is vital. This will ensure that the reserve remains a thriving environment for both surfers and the natural world.

Timeline for Development Milestones

A detailed timeline, outlining key milestones and activities, will provide a roadmap for the reserve’s development. This structured approach will ensure that progress is measured and that the goals of the reserve are met effectively.

Year Milestone Activity
2024 Establish baseline data Collect data on wave conditions, environmental factors, and visitor numbers.
2025 Develop sustainable infrastructure Implement eco-friendly car parks, public transport improvements, and eco-friendly accommodations.
2026 Launch educational initiatives Establish surf schools, courses, and workshops focused on environmental education.
2027 Review and adapt management strategies Analyze collected data and adjust management plans based on findings.

Management and Maintenance

A robust management plan is crucial for the long-term sustainability of the reserve. This plan must address various aspects, from the protection of marine ecosystems to the regulation of visitor numbers. Clear communication channels between stakeholders, including surfers, local communities, and environmental organizations, are vital for ensuring effective management.

  • Collaboration: Establish collaborative partnerships with local communities, conservation groups, and other stakeholders to foster a shared vision for the reserve’s future.
  • Governance: Develop a transparent and effective governance structure that includes representatives from all key stakeholders to ensure that the reserve’s interests are protected.
  • Enforcement: Implement clear guidelines and regulations, ensuring their consistent enforcement to maintain the integrity of the reserve and the environment.

Conclusive Thoughts

North Devon’s new status as a world surfing reserve holds immense potential, promising a vibrant future for surfing in the region. From economic growth to environmental protection, the designation presents both opportunities and challenges. The success of this initiative will depend on collaboration between the community, businesses, and environmental groups. The future of North Devon’s surfing culture hinges on the careful management and responsible use of this unique resource.

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *